Day 11: Heather Construction (The "Cookie" Theory)
- Ira Bashist
- Jan 2
- 2 min read
Welcome to Week 2, Day 11 of My Dad vs. The Algorithm.
Today we are discussing Yarn Composition.
A few days ago, a designer asked my dad, Ira, if we could take our standard white fabric and "dye it Heather Grey."
Ira’s Reaction:
"That’s like asking me to bake chocolate chips into a cookie after I already took it out of the oven. You can't dye 'Heather.' Heather isn't a color you add at the end; it's a recipe you start with at the beginning."
Here is the technical difference between Piece Dye and Heather Construction.
Process A: Piece Dye (Solids)
When you see a solid color t-shirt (Black, Navy, Red), that is usually Piece Dyed.
The Input: We start with 100% natural, off-white cotton yarn.
The Knitting: We knit the fabric. It comes off the machine looking like "Ecru" (natural raw cotton).
The Dyeing: We dip the entire roll of fabric into a dye bath. Every fiber absorbs the color equally.
The Result: A uniform, solid block of color.
The Advantage: Flexibility. You can knit 1,000 lbs of white fabric and decide the colors later.
Process B: Heather Construction (Yarn Dye)
Heather Grey (or any "Melange" color) is not a dip-dye process. It is a Fiber Blend.
The Input: Before the yarn is even spun, the mill mixes black fibers (usually polyester or dyed cotton) with white cotton fibers.
The Spinning: These fibers are twisted together to create a "speckled" yarn. The color is physically locked inside the thread.
The Knitting: We knit this pre-colored yarn.
The Result: A textured, multi-tonal look because the black and white fibers are mixed, not dyed over.
The Limitation: You must commit to the look before you knit. You cannot turn a solid white fabric into a heather fabric later.
The "Cookie" Analogy
This is the easiest way to remember the difference when sourcing:
Piece Dye (Solids) = Frosting. You bake a plain cake, and then you cover it in whatever color frosting you want at the end.
Heather = Chocolate Chip Cookies. The chips (black fibers) are mixed into the dough before baking. You can't add them later.
The Bottom Line
If you want flexibility in your production schedule, stick to Piece Dyes (Solids). You can dye them any color of the rainbow at the last minute.
If you want the texture and depth of a Heather, you must plan ahead. You are buying a specific yarn, not just a dye color.
Ira’s Final Advice:
"If you order the dough, don't ask for chips later. If you want Heather, we have to spin it that way."
Tune in tomorrow for Day 12!
(Missed yesterday's post about weight measurements? Read Day 10: GSM vs. OZ/LY here.)
Need to see the texture up close? Order our Essential Swatch Kit to compare Heather vs. Solid.
Comments